Early Decision and Early Action results arrive in mid-December. There are three outcomes — admitted, denied and deferred — and only two to three weeks between the results and the Regular Decision and ED II deadlines. Here is what each outcome requires, and what to decide before results day, based on the Common App agreement and colleges' official calendars.
|

Early Decision Has Three Outcomes, Not Two — Admitted, Denied or Deferred, and What to Decide Before December

From the first step of your child’s education to the last, Elite Prep is with you.

Once the November 1 and November 15 early applications are in, the house gets a little quieter. Results come in mid-December, and many families assume they can wait and react then. This post argues the opposite.

After early results come out, there are only two or three weeks left. So what to do in each of the three cases — admitted, denied or deferred — has to be decided before results day.

We covered the checks before submitting in The Early Decision Final Checklist, and whether to apply ED at all in Early Decision Is a Contract, Not a Strategy. This post is about what comes next: results day and the two weeks after it.

1. Why decide before results day? Start with the calendar

Put this year’s college calendars side by side and the reason is clear.

College Early results Next deadline
Vanderbilt ED I decisions mid-December ED II and RD due January 1
Duke ED decisions mid-December —
Dartmouth ED decisions by mid-December RD due January 1
MIT EA decisions mid-December Regular Action due January 4

From each admissions office’s 2026-27 calendar. Colleges announce the exact release date through the applicant portal and email.

A student who hears in mid-December and has an application due January 1 has about two weeks. In that stretch, school goes on winter break, and counselors and teachers are hard to reach. Starting Regular Decision essays after the result is too late. And on the day a result arrives, neither a student nor a parent is in a good position to make calm decisions. That is why the plan has to exist first.

2. If your student is admitted — ED and EA are different

An ED admission means keeping a promise. The Common App Early Decision agreement says it directly (Common App ED Agreement, 2026): a student accepted under an early decision plan must promptly withdraw applications to other colleges and make no additional applications to any university in any country. The student isn’t the only one who signs. The counselor and a parent sign too, and the parent’s line says the parent will ensure the student abides by the commitment.

After an ED admission there are three things to do.

  • Withdraw the other applications. That includes EA and RD applications already submitted, and the UC application. Notify each college through its portal or by email.
  • Check the deposit date. Enrollment deadlines for ED admits come sooner than families expect. Vanderbilt’s ED I deposit deadline is December 31.
  • Keep senior-year grades up. An admission rests on finishing senior year as planned. We covered this in Filing the Application Is Not the Finish Line.

Families who applied for financial aid should remember one more thing. The same agreement says an ED candidate seeking financial aid need not withdraw other applications until the student has received notification about financial aid from the admitting institution. The order is: read the aid notification, then withdraw. If the offer makes enrolling difficult, don’t decide alone. Talk to that college’s financial aid office first. The process differs from college to college. You can estimate what your family would actually pay ahead of time with a Net Price Calculator.

An EA admission is different. EA isn’t binding. Your student can hold that offer and compare RD results and financial aid offers until May 1, so there’s no need to rush a deposit. What changes is the RD list. Colleges your student would choose after the one that already said yes can come off it.

3. Deferred isn’t denied. It also isn’t a reason to wait

A deferral means the college made no decision in the early round and will review the application again with the Regular Decision pool. The application is still alive.

The numbers deserve a clear look, though. MIT publishes them (MIT Admissions statistics, Class of 2029).

MIT Early Action (Class of 2029) Students
Applied 12,052
Admitted 721
Deferred to Regular Action 7,486
Deferred applicants admitted in Regular Action 175

More than 60% of early applicants were deferred, and about 2% of those were admitted later. This is one college, and the proportions differ elsewhere. The lesson still holds. A deferral means a chance remains. It doesn’t mean your student can wait on that college. Prepare the RD applications as if the deferral hadn’t happened.

So what should a deferred student send to the college? One rule: send only what the college asks for, in the way it asks.

  • MIT has deferred applicants submit the February Updates & Notes (FUN) Form with midyear grades in mid-February.
  • Dartmouth tells deferred ED applicants to submit a brief update around the Mid-Year Report (January to February), and notes that some may wish to send new test scores or an additional recommendation. Decisions come on or before April 1.

Even these two colleges handle it differently. So the first step is to read the decision letter and the portal instructions all the way through. Sending several letters and recommendations to a college that says not to send more material doesn’t help. If the college does take updates, send a short summary of what’s new since the early application: first-semester senior grades, new awards, progress in an activity. For how colleges track an applicant’s interest, see Demonstrated Interest, School by School.

4. If your student is denied — that college is over, the season isn’t

After a denial in the early round, most colleges won’t take another application from that student in the same year’s Regular Decision. It’s hard to hear, but this result has one advantage: it’s clear. Your student can change direction now, without waiting until late March.

Check two things.

  • The balance of the RD list. If what’s left is only colleges about as selective as the early choice, look at the list again. Make sure it includes enough colleges where admission is likely.
  • ED II. If your student’s second-choice college offers ED II, it’s an option. Vanderbilt’s ED II is due January 1, with decisions in mid-February and a March 1 deposit. Vanderbilt’s ED admit rate for the Class of 2030, ED I and II combined, was 11.9% (Vanderbilt Admissions, February 2026). But ED II is still ED. An admitted student has to attend, and the same three people sign the same agreement again. It’s for a college your student truly wants, and it shouldn’t be used only to raise the odds.

A denial doesn’t mean the whole application was wrong. It is a reason to reread the essays and activity descriptions before the RD applications go out.

5. Five things to do before results day

  • Write the RD essays now. Write them whatever the result turns out to be. If the ED answer is yes, they’ll never be used, and that’s a happy way to waste them.
  • Agree on an ED II candidate as a family. Decided on the day of a denial or deferral, the choice gets made by emotion.
  • Finish the financial aid paperwork. An ED admit’s aid notification comes only after every document is in.
  • Check the portal login. Results are posted to the college’s portal. Every year some families spend results day hunting for a password.
  • Put “what we do the next day” on one page, for each outcome. If admitted, which applications get withdrawn. If deferred, what to read and what to prepare. If denied, which applications go out and by when.

6. Notes from 23 Years of Counseling

  • What parents misunderstand most: They take a deferral as a denial. On results evening in mid-December, a mother called me and said, “It’s a rejection.” We looked at the portal together, and it said Deferred, not Denied. But the student was already discouraged. The first part of winter break slipped away, and the RD essays hadn’t been touched.
  • The pattern I’ve seen: Even an ED admission comes with a to-do list. That’s why the next thing I say after congratulations on admission day is, “Now let’s clean up the rest of the applications.” A few days pass in the joy of the admission. Then in early January another college emails asking for a missing document, and only then does the family realize the EA and RD applications were never withdrawn. By that point, checking the financial aid package and the deposit deadline had been pushed back too.
  • What to do now: The three months after a deferral came down to the response, not luck. One student booked a counseling session the day after the deferral notice. We first checked whether the college’s instructions allowed additional material, then sent a concise letter of continued interest (LOCI) with the first-semester grades (Mid-Year Report) and new accomplishments since the fall. The RD applications were finished without wavering, and the good news came in late March. A deferral isn’t the end. It’s a second review.

On results day, what a parent says

An early result is one college’s decision in one year. It isn’t a verdict on your child. Whatever the result is, the mood at home is different when the next day’s tasks are already written down. Before mid-December, sit down with your student for thirty minutes and talk through all three cases. And remember that a deferral isn’t a denial, and that it also isn’t a reason to wait.

For a closer look at your family’s plan, reach out to your nearest Elite Prep:

www.eliteprep.com/locations

한국어 버전: 조기전형 결과는 둘이 아니라 셋입니다


📍 Elite Prep Suwanee

From SAT preparation to financial aid, and AP and college courses accepted by universities across the United States — brought to you by Elite Prep Suwanee.

Andy Lee / Director of Elite Prep Suwanee powered by Elite Open School

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *